The Kerfluffle With New York City’s Anti-Teen Pregnancy Ads

nyc-anti-teen-pregnancyDo you all remember those ads a looooooong time ago intended to keep kids off drugs? One of the famous ones was the famous egg in the frying-pan “This is your brain. This is your brain on drugs.” I can’t lie, that commercial did not want me to stay off of drugs. It made me want to fry an egg and more specifically see if I could get an egg to sizzle like that in a frying pan. I was an adventurous scamp. Once, I wanted to smoke a cigarette. I thought cigarettes were just rolled up paper. I lit a piece of rolled up paper.

I didn’t burn the house down that day. But I did come close. Somewhere along the way I did learn that if there’s a fire you stomp it out. In fact, the A-town stomp? Yeah. All me.

My point here is that kids don’t give a flying fig about ads intended to scare them into NOT doing something. In fact, I’d almost be willing to bet that most of those ads in subway cars aren’t exactly shaming any teenagers into not becoming pregnant. Hell, the kids are probably looking at how cute those kids are. They’re totes adorbs.

A lot has been made of the ads with talking heads from various arenas taking their shots at Bloomberg and the ads (and some supporting by saying that others are missing the point). And real talk, if I thought that teenagers really cared about a subway ad, then I might agree, but the truth is, kids are not reading those ads and thinking about how being a single mother is going to ruin their life (not that I think this way, but one of the ads implies this). Or thinking that they’ll avoid poverty if they have their kid within a “stable”, married two parent household. Those are thoughts and convos many of us had after college, when life got real and we started to give f*cks.

In fact, I’d wager that any teenager who cared about those ads, cared before the ads showed up and they’re just reinforcing what they already think and know. And the kids who haven’t had those influences placed into their lives to give them that type of knowledge, well, again, they’re not really going to internalize how much money a kid costs. Hell, adults aren’t able to fully grasp it until you have one and you have to figure out insurance and schooling, etc.

And trust me people, the school struggle…that’s that sh*t I don’t like. It might be the most frustrating part to date. Then again, I live in a city where school choice is a hot topic because our public schools are questionable unless you live in the well-to-do (read: white) part of the city, our charter schools are allegedly siphoning off the public schools ability to do its service, and private schools cost as much as my undergrad education.

The point is, kids aren’t adept at making those leaps and fully getting the gravity of a situation. This is why ads like that don’t sink in. There are a million cautionary tales running rampant everywhere. One more subway ad isn’t going to do the trick. [Panama Note: I do think that something is better than nothing, but it does help if the something is actually a something.] Thing is, my guess is (and Melissa Harris-Perry alluded to this in her clip, I’m too lazy to look up stats) that teen pregnancy is down everywhere. What has happened is a focus on prevention via protection and knowledge about STDs and the like. Scaring a kid with a cute kid ain’t going to cut it. Scaring a kid with a picture of a burnt up looking wang? Yeah, that might do the trick.

And yes, I just placed a “note” in a post I wrote.

Scaring little girls into thinking that if she lets Dontelquestejuan get her goodies, her ladybits might start to resemble a metal barbed wire fence in East Germany? Yeah, that can do the trick. When I was in middle school, we were forced to watch a live childbirth. Man that scared the holy hell out of me.

I’m inclined to believe that while many little boys can talk a girl into some sexing, that smarter little girls and boys leads to less sex at an earlier, unprepared age. So scaring the sh*t out of little chilluns with bodily harm and damage? My guess is that worked somehow. Plus, it seems like kids nowadays are just that much smarter in a worldly sense regarding the dangers and ills of society because of overexposure to all of them.  Even teen smoking is down.

At the end of the day I get the criticism of the ads. Even if they’re target is teenagers who probably don’t care, the message is still one that tends to attempt to assume that a single mother (assuming most of these kids end up with their mommies) is going to have a harder go at it than necessary if they make the “right” choices. And that’s probably accurate. Hell it’s not probably, it is accurate. Kids, and specifically babies, are a lot of work. It’s doable and a vast many of us have experienced a one-parent household. But many folks from that life also didn’t want that life for themselves so they attempted to make other choices. A little support and communication about life and the lessons you’ll learn goes a long way.

And if you throw a burnt out wang in the mix, well you just might scare somebody into becoming a 30-year-old virgin.

So, VSBers, what do you think about the ads?

-VSB P aka THE ARSONIST aka MR. I GOT A KID, KEEP IT MOVING aka GIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIRL HE A 3

 

  • Yoles

    i think that i am the only person that didn’t find the ads troublesome. do i think teens pay attention, most of the time not BUT i do think that in this capitalist/consumerist society we are living in that the teens are thinking more about themselves and what they want and they aint got time for no crumb snatching basta*ds (children are a blessing, God bless them and so on and so forth-no shots)

    i will say that pictures and video of extreme STDs are the scariest things i have seen medically in my whole life, no injury or even maggots can compare to the meatus of a pe.nis being ate away and ravaged by infection. trust me!

    i think both types of ads should be used an all encompassing approach to telling this kids MAKE BETTER DECISIONS please!!

    sidebar: baby girl on the bottom left is speaking to my uterus… geez louise she is too cute :D

    • http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com Val

      Hiya, Yolie!

      *waves*

      :-)

      Yep, that little girl is a cutie.

      And, I agree about teens now being much more me orientated, which may keep some of them from having kids if you can show them what they will miss out on if they have a kid.

      • Yoles

        Hi Val :D

        i agree… do anything to show these kids that there are consequences to every. single. action! whether it is missing out on louboutin shoes or the chance to be a rappers groupie (we will deal with that later) or looking good, not getting fat, decreasing dating market value, whatever…

        • http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com Val

          “rappers groupie (we will deal with that later)”

          Lol. Yeah and I’ll remind you to bring it up again later.

    • Think2Inspire

      “i will say that pictures and video of extreme STDs are the scariest things i have seen medically in my whole life, no injury or even maggots can compare to the meatus of a pe.nis being ate away and ravaged by infection. trust me!”

      I remember seeing one of those videos in middle school where I shrugged it off while everyone else was screaming and hiding in class. That night I had the scariest nightmare about warts and gonorrhea. Most effect burf control. EVER

      About a year ago I was giving my brother the talk. He cut me off saying “Fcuk sex, I googled herpes. I’m never having sex!” lol

      • Rewind

        Give that young man a gold star.

      • Asiyah

        “About a year ago I was giving my brother the talk. He cut me off saying “Fcuk sex, I googled herpes. I’m never having sex!” lol”

        LOL too cute

    • http://stanoffewwords.wordpress.com Tristan

      #teambottomleftgirl and she got the funniest/realist message

      • Rewind

        I think that poster should be put in every clothing store a teenage girl could buy clothes from

        • camilleblue

          Rewind!!! I is free *giggles*

          • Rewind

            lmao you escaped again!

    • LMNOP

      “sidebar: baby girl on the bottom left is speaking to my uterus… geez louise she is too cute”

      Yeah I think that is the problem with having cute babies in anti-pregnancy ads.

    • Malik

      I had a dream about Cuba and was with some Cubans.

      • Yoles

        Vayamos Malik

      • Asiyah

        I’m glad you kinda clarified that you were referring to the island and not the actor lol

    • AmaniKwenu

      “they aint got time for no crumb snatching basta*ds (children are a blessing, God bless them and so on and so forth-no shots)”

      LOL. This made me laugh so much this morning. Thank you.

    • http://www.twitter.com/IluminatiNYC Todd

      I could help out with your uterus needs. *cackle*

      • http://saysmeblog.wordpress.com/ Aly

        smh

        • Yoles

          + me

    • http://saysmeblog.wordpress.com/ Aly

      no injury or even maggots can compare to the meatus of a pe.nis being ate away and ravaged by infection. trust me!

      Eww. Yeah, I’m gonna have to trust you on that one. Hey, did you get your work schedule? Are you going to the meetup? (crossing fingers)

      • Yoles

        i got my work schedule and i am off April 6 & 7 2013!!!!

        who in nyc wants to carpool with me?? lets do this :D

        Rewind
        Todd
        H.H.H
        Shamira
        Asiyah
        Muze
        Esa

        • http://saysmeblog.wordpress.com/ Aly

          Yay!!! Can’t wait to meet you!

          • Kema

            Same here!!! Woooo!

        • Asiyah

          Hmmm…I’ve always wanted to go to D.C. I’m down!

        • http://missrosen.wordpress.com esa

          i dont know how to drive. i’m from new york ~*~

          • camilleblue

            esa – i’m not trying to be funny, but that just boggles my mind…even if you don’t have a car…you really don’t know how to drive? i’m in the midwest and you best believe that your @ss will be straight stuck on stupid w/o a car, let alone a license…

            • http://www.twitter.com/IluminatiNYC Todd

              camille, that’s not that unusual in NYC. When you have a quality mass transit system that runs 24 hours, you can function in large parts of the city without a car.

              • camilleblue

                i know…i mean, i know how nyc works…but, but, but…don’t you just need to have a license…just in case??? lol…shyt in my state you d@mn near ain’t a living being w/o a license…

                • http://www.twitter.com/IluminatiNYC Todd

                  I don’t know about other places, but I know in NY, they’ll give you a non-driving State ID. If you’re poor enough, the state will pay for it for you.

                  • http://missrosen.wordpress.com esa

                    yes ! i got it when i turned 21. called it my drinking license ~

                    still have that same photo. all attitude and hair ~*~

            • http://missrosen.wordpress.com esa

              it is funnnny ~ i love it. i usually walk everywhere. like seriously, i can do five miles feeling like Rihanna the whole time.

              nahh i cannot be driving cars or riding bikes or things with wheels in this town. trains are entertaining, but i cant wait til the weatther gets betta so i can slink back and forth across the Brooklyn Bridge every day ~

        • CNotes

          You all are getting me excited!! : )

          • http://twitter.com/SoulaPowa SoulaPowa

            What’s the event for the road trip to D.C. that the NYC VSBs/VSSs are coming for?

            • Marshal

              Well, I’m already in DC and I hve no clue what this is myself

              • camilleblue

                it’s the 5 year anniversary meet up that the VSB crew is throwing..

                • CNotes

                  Yep….what camilleblue said. I believe it is April 6th at Liv.

                  • Marshal

                    Hmmmm, a Monday, huh. I haven’t been to the last few Liv events as my internship with DC Metro Police has me working 14hr shifts on Saturdays, so I should be able to go to this one- providing I don’t have Finals that week

                    • CNotes

                      April 6th is a Saturday. Hopefully you can make it.

        • http://www.twitter.com/IluminatiNYC Todd

          Email me on Monday. I should know my schedule by then.

        • Wild Cougar

          Bring Malik or else.

          • camilleblue

            awwwwww..shyt now…

          • Asiyah

            the cougar has spoken

    • http://www.styleillusions.com WIP

      I think the images may have unwanted affect though. Kids will think that someone has to look sick or body parts need to *look* sick to be sick.

      • Royale W. Cheese

        Good point.

    • http://verysmartbrothas.com Panama Jackson

      I don’t have a problem with the ads existence. Hell, whatever works. I just don’t think they’re going to be effective. Like you said, one of the kids is talking to your uterus. LOTS OF PEOPLE TALK.

  • http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com Val

    Is it “chilluns” or Chirrens? I’m not being a wiseazz either. I’ve just never heard “chillums” before. Am I the only one who thought/ thinks it’s “chirrens”? Or maybe it’s a regional thing?

    • AfroPetite

      +1 for chirrens and I do think it is regional

    • Think2Inspire

      I heard and read ‘churrin’ and ‘chirren.’ I saw ‘chillun’ and thought it had to do with chicken.

      • http://www.twitter.com/mcnairian5 McNairian

        No “s” unless it’s possessive case. Haha!

      • http://saysmeblog.wordpress.com/ Aly

        …or chitlins? *gags*

    • Keisha

      I’ve heard both…my grandma used “chilluns” all the time. She lived in Mississippi. Maybe it is a regional thing.

    • http://verysmartbrothas.com Panama Jackson

      I think it can be what you want it to be..in living color.

    • miss t-lee

      Chirrens is what my grandmother used to say. (TX)

      • Tx10inch

        Bad azz mistake is what MY granny used to say.

        • camilleblue

          womp! womp!

          • Tx10inch

            Nah, that wasn’t a joke that fell flat. My brother and I were demon spawns for a while. We accidently burned down her apartment complex when I was 7. Long story…

            *Bernie Mac voice* let’s move on.

            • camilleblue

              oh, i knew it wasn’t a joke…that’s what the womp was for…i figure you were a lil bad azz! :)

            • http://missrosen.wordpress.com esa

              i love back story ..

        • miss t-lee

          LMAO!! TX!!! You Granny was hilarious.

    • http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com Val

      Okay, seems like it’s a regional thing.

  • Cheech

    Uh that doesn’t work lol. What did work for a lot of kids in my area, was when the Nigerian association in my area tricked all the kids into getting a massive sex ed lesson by buying all of us a trip to Six flags with a catch: we got the talk. So after they fed all the kids food, they did a massive slideshow showing the effects of various stds on body parts such as eyes and lips. I swear very few people ate for the rest of that day. Those lessons stuck with a lot of us and most people haven’t produced babies since.

    • rooseveltdunn

      yep sounds like a Nigerian style tactic to me lol

    • Yoles

      the first time i heard of/seen gonorrhea of the eyes, throat & rectum (which had painful discharge of bloody pus from the rectum) i was done, DONE, so, so finished. i felt scared. it also took me a minute to figure out how it got into the eye in the first place ;)

      sidebar: the treatment for gonorrhea is injections inserted in the glutes. it is the hardest liquid ever to push. the thickest medicine ever with a seriously large needle at that… USE CONDOMS

      *paid for this was free but, so needs to be said association of america llc, inc*

      • http://www.twitter.com/IluminatiNYC Todd

        Sounds like someone got worked over in lots and lots of ways. Ick!

      • curlygirl

        Wait! How DID it get into the eye? Apparently I’m only into “vanilla/plain” sex.

        • Yoles

          via ejaculate in the literal eye

          • http://missrosen.wordpress.com esa

            that is so rude.

            • AmaniKwenu

              LOL!!! I know! Why would anyone do that?!?

      • http://saysmeblog.wordpress.com/ Aly

        Yolie! You’re grossing me out this morning lol! But you’re also making me think about safe sex, so… mission accomplished??

        • Yoles

          exactly!! Aly :D

      • BriA

        *Puts down chicken biscuit.* Thanks a bunch!:-(

      • http://missrosen.wordpress.com esa

        THIS would make the best P.S.A.

        word, they put foot fungus ads on the trains. that ishh kills me. course it’s not as bad as homeless men feet. the live show takes it to the next level. then there are dudes who aint got feet. remember honey on the skateboard with no legs back in the days ?

        wait. whas my point ? right. REAL ADS. fear has power and control. cute babies, cute fonts, cute words = mixed messages.

        who are these creative directors. they need to hire CP+B who did that Truth campaign for smoking. that ishh was real.

        • Ms. Bridget

          was that the inside out one? if yes, I still remember it from back in the day.

      • Sweet GA Brown

        In bootcamp everyone gets a penicillin shot weeks before they test for stds. They tell you to take down your pants to only expose the meaty part of your cheek, bend you over a stretcher with a group of other recruits and everybody gets the shot. Its a real pain in the a$$.

    • http://www.twitter.com/IluminatiNYC Todd

      I approve of Nigerian sex ed tactics. Do they do contract work? :)

  • ‘L’

    Marketing 101 requires that the seller knows & understand their audience, therefore the adds reach an audience, just not the intended audience. If they want 2 reach their audience they should depict some teenage moms & dads coping w/ an infant.

    • AfroPetite

      They need to show kids a woman giving birth naturally to a breeched baby with no epidural. These girls out here thinking labor and delivery is a breeze since they get to look forward to being numb from the waist down. Nah, show them some gritty isn…

      • http://www.iamyourpeople.com I Am Your People

        I have witness this. 4’11 woman who was normally 85lbs gave birth to a 9lb baby. I almost grabbed a plastic knife and gave myself a hysterectomy.

        • AfroPetite

          I’m not here for babies over 7lb 5oz I’m doing thorough research on potential mates and their birth weights.

          • Think2Inspire

            My boyfriend is 6’3 and has a tank head talmbout he was a ten pound baby. At a whole foot shorter I gave him the 0.o look.

            #UterusonStrike

            • AfroPetite

              I’m too small for 10lbs of anything to be lurking in my womb like that!!!

              • Yoles

                i’m not small but we ALL start out with the same size uterus & mine doesn’t have space for any 10lb being either… you petites can not have that stance all to yourselves… no ma’am

                • camilleblue

                  #uteruswars

                • AfroPetite

                  Trueeeee

            • camilleblue

              lol…not the tank head!

    • http://verysmartbrothas.com Panama Jackson

      I always thought that giving kids those baby alive dolls worked. Like if you show people how much work something can be, its more effective than telling them how their life will be affected.

      • camilleblue

        nah…b/c when u get tired of them you can just turn ‘em off…or throw them down without repercussions from child welfare….

        • BriA

          Right! I took one home in Middle School because I thought they were cute, and when that thang kept on crying, I put it in the car seat in my Mom’s car for the weekend. When I turned it on that Monday and my teacher took the electronic box out, I had nearly 100 neglects and cries clocked on it. Needless to say, I don’t have children and am 95% sure I don’t want any.

          • Sweet GA Brown

            Girl in high school that baby woke me and my mother up at night, I was at work with the baby, on the train with the baby, strangers trying to look at the baby like its real and Im to young to have one. That baby stressed me out. OAN: My homegirls bought hers clothes and Jordans and she named her and the baby had bibs and headbands to match. SMH.

            • camilleblue

              when keepin it real goes wrong…

          • JanuaryBabe

            I am crying!!!! So funny! Good for you! Children ain’t no joke and parenting never ends….IJS

      • AfroPetite

        I opted out of the baby doll and wore the pregnancy suit. I didn’t have time to lend to a fake baby.

  • http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com Val

    As for the ads. I don’t think they will hurt. They may prompt some teens to think twice or even three times before having unprotected sex.

    The anecdotal evidence that I’ve heard is that teen girls who don’t feel loved are more likely to have a kid. So, the message really ought to be to parents/ grandparents, etc., to be more loving and to be very vocal about loving their daughters.

    That way girls won’t think that a baby and/ or boy is where they can get the love they need from.

    Oh, and sports are also a great way to prevent or reduce the chance of teen pregnancy. I’ve read that girls who participate in sports are much less likely to get pregnant.

    • Latonya

      I don’t think an ad is gone to prevent a teen from getting pregnant. I always felt like it is up to the individual to make the right choice in life. Ads like this remaind me of the don’t smoke, or this is your brain on drugs. The “don’t smoke” ad made people go out and smoke more. lol

      • http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com Val

        Yeah, alone the ads may not work. But, if you add good parenting and re-enforcement at school to the mix then there might some success.

      • LMNOP

        you know what though? There has been a massive change in children’s attitudes about smoking in the past 20-30 years.

        • http://saysmeblog.wordpress.com/ Aly

          Very true.

        • curlygirl

          There’s been a change in adult’s attitudes toward smoking. In my state, we’ve kicked smokers out of restaraunts, bowling alleys, bars, off of school campuses. You gets no love as a smoker.

          • Rewind

            Same here in NY. They can’t do shyte. You can’t even smoke 100ft in front of certain buildings and the taxes here are the highest in the nation.

          • LMNOP

            yeah, this is actually a great example of a wide spread societal change in attitudes and behaviors, and it seems like there is A LOT behind it, education, high taxes, smoke-free workplaces, support for people quitting smoking, etc.

      • http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com Val

        I hear that in Chicago and NYC a pack of cigs costs between $12 and $15. That’s insane. All that is doing is creating an illegal underground market for cigarettes.

        • Asiyah

          Pretty much.

    • http://www.twitter.com/IluminatiNYC Todd

      You’re right…but no parent is ever a “bad parent”, even if Stevie Wonder blindfolded could see how much of a screw-up they are. The bad parents will say, “welp…they ain’t talking about me” before starting own in-home edition of WWE Smackdown with their kids.

      Oh, and I found out this weekend that if I’m interested in getting my daughter into sports, I need to hide it from my mom. When I hinted at it (though mainly for the ego trip of seeing my girl were #14 and be a power forward like dear old dad), she was against it for being “too butchy”. Oh, and in this same convo, she actively bragged about NOT being involved in my schooling, all while my daughter’s hair was being braided by her hairdresser. Sigh…*smh*

      • camilleblue

        nah…put her in sports…tell your mom she’ll be like skylar diggins…

        • http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com Val

          Skylar is one of my favorite players. I wish I had cable so I could see her play in the tournament.

      • http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com Val

        Yeah, Todd, sports are great for a girls self-esteem, gives them confidence and usually keeps them from getting preggers. Plus, if she’s really good she can get a scholarship to college.

        • http://www.twitter.com/IluminatiNYC Todd

          Duly noted. Though I should have caught it from all the PSAs on all the WNBA games I’ve watched over the past 15 years. LOL

          • http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com Val

            Stop it!

            • http://www.twitter.com/IluminatiNYC Todd

              In all seriousness, I do watch a lot of WNBA basketball. As a result, I’ve caught a lot of the PSAs about self-esteem. I didn’t give it much though…until I met my tall, lanky sister-in-law and all the crap she’s gone through.

              Lesson? Never mock PSAs, especially on “women’s” programming.

              • http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com Val

                Okay, your “lol” confused me into thinking you were making a joke about the WNBA.

                I love the WNBA but since I don’t have cable I can’t watch it anymore. :-(

                • Marshal

                  Lisa Leslie, Diana Turasi, Swin Cash(I didn’t spell her first name right, Sorry), Candace Parker, Sheryl Swoops, and a host of other WNBA stars are the most athletic and amazing I’ve ever seen.

                  Can’t wait to see Skylar and Griner in the pros

                  • http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com Val

                    I don’t have cable, Marshal, but I’m going to get it just so I can see Brittany and Candice play each other for the first time next year. That’s going to be amazing.

                    Ans all the players you mention are Hall of Famers for sure.

                    • Marshal

                      I loved to sem tem play and they definitely are Future and/or Hall of Fame caliber

  • rooseveltdunn

    Teenagers are self absorbed and often not truly in tune with how the world works, stuck in between the world of children and adults they are big enough to make decisions that will affect them forever but not mature enough to always appreciate the consequences of such decisions…the ads may seem a little campy (I find that showing them the pics of genital warts and people dying of AIDS is more effective) but the intentions are good, there is a correlation between good sex ed and low pregnancy rates among teen age kids so maybe these will work…plus I doubt anyone would want NYC covered in posters of diseased genitalia.

    • Rewind

      True. The ads have a soft touch, meant to be more annoying rather than informative. Kids don’t give a damn anyway. A teenager on the train is either with friends going crazy or having music blasting in their ear.

      The true way kids learn if they want kids or not is through their friends who already have kids or family that have struggles with kids.

  • Marshal

    I grew up with D.A.R.E and G.R.E.A.T- both were campaigns and organizations that were about Avoiding Gangs, Drugs, and Gun Violence- nationally, the rates are down, but tell that to the people in Chicago, NYC, Philly, etc. I also went to a Catholic school from 2nd-10th grade where we had Operation Keepsake, which was Abstinence of Sex until Marriage- out of 40 us in my classes from 2000-2003, 36 (including myself) wer having Sex at a Young Age. Hell,I lost my Virginity at 13 and had no clue what it Meant “to Me”. I get the post is saying that the Ads aren’t going to do much for Some, but there are Teens and Kids that do see and listen to that and the other organizations/programs that I referenced and it must have made a difference “For Them”.

    Those subway ads aren’t saying anything that we already say in casual conversations or in our own way of shaming, clowning, and criticizing Fast Ass Kids today- especially when it was Us that was Reckless and Wild ( we weren’t Chief Keef-ing it, Twerk Teaming, and going Project X and Steubenville in the 80s and 90s). I have Zero Problems with the ads, if Society, specifically the Black Community, wants the days where it Took a Village to Raise Children, then we also have to acknowledge the Neighbors, Aunts/Uncles, and Old Folks who were saying Much Harsher things than what’s on those ads- Kids were sent away to “camp” and “boarding school” for having Sex at a Young Age and/or Getting Prego. I’ve heard stories from my parents and older relatives that would scare the living crap out of these kids and teens today, so all this outrage is Pathetic and CLEARLY misses the point of what we All Know is going on.

    Gun Violence is “down”, yet the U.S. leads all over nations in Gun Deaths; Abortions are “decreasing” yet the U.S. ALSO leads the rest of the world in that; Unplanned Pregnancies are “lower” than they have been, Unemployment is Falling, so on and so forth, but there Are People who Still Suffer and there’s Still a Problem – not a Tragic one- but a Problem nonetheless

  • Malik

    Right no. It yield very little, if any, positive examples. More grassroots community sex ed discussions are what is necessary not lame advertisements. This is just a waste of money.

    • Marshal

      Would you say then that the Rapit Up/Wrap it Up ads and commercials that have been shown for decases towards us Men worked or not worked? Again, I may have thought they were lame but out of 7 Guys 4 may have bought in and heeded that advice. These ads, like many things that may be Rhetorical to us are better than Nothing at All.

      • Malik

        Free condoms have helped me practice safe sex more than any ad has.

        • IcePrincess3

          Mane I can’t do free condoms, cuz they usually Lifestyles. I cant f*ck wit it (pardon the pun lol). They break all the time, they’re the worst! #TEAMTROJANALLDAY

        • Marshal

          Of course, Condoms don’t come with a No Sex until Marriage label or warning…..

          The ads are sort of sayng Both, depending on which one you’re looking at

  • http://www.wddij.com RuthlessWonder

    In the end I think despite the joking nature of the last line that may be the right way to do things. We know that straight up scare tactics don’t work because they seem to be too far removed from the audience. We know the use of adorable kids and the doll like nature of babies is really not going to work. And I’m sure there are some “Stay with her if you knock her up” ads out there, I just haven’t seen them. A comprehensive approach is the logical one.

    I remember the old health videos. Sadly I don’t think they update them often enough. I remember in high school ours was a 70′s and 80′s filled trip into hilarious yesteryear. They don’t have to be stodgy either. There are enough independent film makers who could use a check to get these things done right.

    But combine the horrors of sketchy partners, the reality of children at young age, and a logical, rational, non-hyperbole filled showing of the impact on the life of a parent…well I think you get Pursuit of Happiness meets Precious but it would work really well. Just go fake documentary style. As for the ads you’re talking about. Eh, I think you hit the nail on the head. The ones who would pay attention already know this. The ones who don’t know this stuff, likely won’t pay any attention.

    • http://verysmartbrothas.com Panama Jackson

      I agree with that. There’s lots of ways to show kids what’s really up.

    • Rewind

      You’ve got a point. But the people who are behind these campaigns are so out of touch with reality. Marketing teams don’t mesh well with artists and thinkers who bring the good ideas to the table. They always muddle up something refreshing with something old & dead. That’s why despite there being better ways to go about this, they will never do it.

  • AfroPetite

    Yes for the Shoshana-ism!!!

    This past episode made me want to smack Hannah and shove that Q-tip further down her ear.

    On to the topic at hand. In 5th grade I, along with my peers, were required to take a sex education class. Females had a class separate from the males and we all learned about our menstrual cycles, how babies are made/birthed, and all the nasty diseases running rampant in the streets. Needless to say, that video did nothing for two girls in my class who became pregnant 2 years after watching that film. I don’t know what will discourage teens from trying to get pregnant especially seeing how it’s romanticized by MTV.

    Despite being educated on sex from adults, I find that many kids seek out sexual advice from other clueless friends who have older siblings that will “school” them on the subject. I remember my first conversation about sex happened in elementary school as well. We were a year from moving onto middle school and my friend was talking to a group of girls about how all the middle school girls were “popping cherries”. If I remember correctly, my friend said that when a boy has sex with a girl, she feels something inside of her “pop”. As other girls inquired about what was supposed to pop, all she could offer was “you’ll know it when it happens” (0_o)

    • http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com Val

      Middle school sex experts are usually the ones who end-up preggers in high school.

    • http://www.twitter.com/Bmorebmw Tentpole

      That’s called peer pressure.